What are the opinions of scholars and their evidence regarding acting upon a weak hadith in matters for which no other evidence has been transmitted, and does this apply to every matter for which only a weak hadith has been transmitted, even if it contradicts a qiyas (analogical deduction)? And does this include matters such as rinsing the mouth, sniffing water into the nose, continuity, and uttering the name of Allah in wudu and ghusl if their hadiths are weak, or is it limited to matters for which there is no textual evidence or qiyas except this weak hadith?
Scholars hold diverse opinions regarding the use of weak hadith in matters of virtuous deeds (Fada'il al-A'mal). Most permit its use under certain conditions, while others absolutely prohibit it. However, Ahl al-Hadith (the People of Hadith) and others unanimously agree on using weak hadith for virtuous deeds, but not for legal rulings (Ahkam) or theological beliefs (Aqa'id).
In general, scholars prioritize a weak hadith over qiyas (analogical reasoning) if there is no conflicting evidence. It is important to note that a weak hadith is not synonymous with a fabricated (batil) or denounced (munkar) one.
Regarding the tasmiyah (uttering "Bismillah"), rinsing the mouth (madhmadha), and sniffing water into the nose (istinshaq) in wudu (ablution) and ghusl (ritual bath): - Madhmadha and istinshaq are supported by authentic hadith. - Tasmiyah for wudu is mentioned in hadith that are not entirely free from weakness, but their collective strength mutually reinforces them. Some scholars have authenticated the hadith "There is no wudu for one who does not mention Allah's name upon it." - No weak hadith has been narrated concerning tasmiyah for ghusl. Those who deem it obligatory base their ruling on qiyas. - The uninterrupted sequence (muwalat) in wudu is indicated by authentic hadith. Scholars have differed on how these hadith are to be understood, but the most apparent opinion is that muwalat is obligatory unless there is an excuse.
Summarized from the full answer at Ftawy · reviewed Sep 2, 2026
Read the full answer on Ftawyhttps://ftawy.com/en/questions/154510