Back to search
The question

How sound is the story of Al-Tabarani, Abu Al-Shaykh, and Abu Bakr Al-Manqari complaining of hunger at the grave of the Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him, and a 'Alawi bringing them food by order of the Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him, in a dream?

Share this answer

Source: FtawySummarized from the full answer at Ftawy · imported Sep 2, 20261 min readAlso available in العربية
The answer

This story cannot be relied upon to prove rulings or beliefs. Ibn al-Jawzi and al-Dhahabi mentioned it using the weak صيغة التمريض (passive or unconfirmed form) "ruwiya" (it was narrated). Furthermore, signs of fabrication are evident in this story, including: the contradiction in the narration regarding the cause of hunger, al-Tabarani's rejection of Ibn al-Muqri', the falsity of the 'Alawi's claim that he complained to the Prophet, and the unknown identity of this 'Alawi. One should not occupy oneself with such stories unless they possess an authentic chain of narration.

Summarized from the full answer at Ftawy · imported

Read the full answer on Ftawy
Where this answer came from
Source platform
Ftawy
Original fatwa ID
1998
Imported
Translation status
Source text, unreviewed
Read the full ruling
Read the full answer on Ftawy