Back to search

What is your guidance regarding Ibn Taymiyyah's statement that whoever comes to the grave of a righteous man, stands by it, and asks him to supplicate to Allah for him, is not committing shirk (polytheism) but rather an innovation (bid'ah) and a forbidden form of seeking intercession (tawassul), and his distinction between being near to and far from the grave, where he considered the latter shirk by consensus, unlike the former?

1 min readAlso available in العربية

Visiting graves, supplicating there, and seeking aid from their occupants fall into three categories:

1. Shirk (Polytheism): Asking the deceased for a need, such as: "Forgive me." 2. Bid'ah (Innovation): Requesting supplication from the deceased or the absent, such as: "Ask your Lord for us." The Companions and the Salaf did not do this, and it is a means leading to Shirk. 3. Makrooh (Disliked) or Forbidden: Seeking intercession through the status or sanctity of someone with Allah, such as: "O Allah, by the status of so-and-so, do such-and-such for me." The Companions did not do this; instead, they resorted to seeking intercession through the supplication of a living person.

Summarized from the full answer at Ftawy · reviewed Sep 2, 2026

Read the full answer on Ftawy