What is the ruling on masturbating unintentionally without ejaculating, and does it differ from masturbating by hand? What is the difference between the white fluid that came out the first time and the clear, viscous fluid that came out the second time? And is ignorance an excuse in such matters?
Masturbation is the conscious inducement of semen discharge by any means. It is forbidden and has harmful effects. Furthermore, fondling the penis with the intention of arousal, without ejaculation, is also impermissible. For a detailed distinction between manī (semen) and madhī (pre-ejaculatory fluid) and their respective rulings, one can refer to detailed fatwas. As for the ruling on being ignorant of its prohibition, a distinction is made between the ignorant person and the knowledgeable person; ignorance is excused in matters of subsidiary rulings (furū') but not in foundational ones (usūl).
Summarized from the full answer at Ftawy · reviewed Sep 2, 2026
Read the full answer on Ftawyhttps://ftawy.com/en/questions/105930