Back to search

Does the questioner's asking the Sheikh about menstruation issues, after he had asked her not to ask him and to suffice with asking the female muftiya, constitute breaking a promise and entering into one of the characteristics of hypocrites?

1 min readAlso available in العربية

What you did by breaking the promise — if you had committed not to ask him again — there is no sin in it, as long as you intended to fulfill it at the time of your speaking, and then you saw a benefit in breaking it. This is not among the characteristics of hypocrites, because breaking a promise is blameworthy only if the intention to break it accompanies the promise. However, if one intended to fulfill it and then an impediment arose or a different opinion occurred to him, then the characteristic of hypocrisy has not manifested from him. It has been reported in the hadith: "If a man promises his brother, and his intention is to fulfill it, but he does not fulfill it, there is no sin upon him."

Summarized from the full answer at Ftawy · reviewed Sep 2, 2026

Read the full answer on Ftawy