What is your opinion on Tafsir Al-Waseet by Tantawi and Aysar Al-Tafasir by As'ad Hawmad? Are they in line with the methodology of Ahlus-Sunnah wal-Jama'ah? Can the verse from Surat An-Nahl, ayah 25, "without knowledge," apply to a disobediently adorned (mutabarrijah) girl who was emulated by another in her adornment, even if she did not verbally invite her, but rather by her very conduct?

We apologize for not being able to give a general ruling on the two books due to insufficient knowledge of them.

As for the verse in An-Nahl (The Bees), it indicates that the disobedient will bear the sins of those who imitated them in their deviation. The texts of revelation confirm this: whoever calls to misguidance or establishes a bad precedent bears its sin and the sin of those who act upon it after him. This applies to the unveiled woman; it is feared that she will bear the sin of the girls who imitate her in immodest display, even if she did not explicitly call them to it.