Back to search

1. Is it a condition for those with excuses, when performing apparent (Suri) combining of prayers with a single ablution, that the Asr prayer be immediately after the Dhuhr prayer? And is it permissible to pray a supererogatory prayer or wait a few minutes between the two obligatory prayers, or is the condition that the Takbir for the second obligatory prayer be immediately after the Taslim of the first? 2. Is it a condition for one afflicted with urinary incontinence to perform Istinja' (cleansing of private parts), or is ablution upon the entry of the prayer time sufficient? And is it valid to perform Istinja' before the entry of the prayer time and ablution after the entry of the prayer time to catch the congregational prayer? 3. If the incontinence is not controlled, is it obligatory for the afflicted person to choose a time free from the emission for ablution and prayer? And is it obligatory for them to repeat ablution and prayer if something is emitted during them, or is one ablution after the entry of the prayer time sufficient, and they may pray even if something is emitted? And is it permissible for them to combine prayers apparently (Suri) and truly (Haqiqi)? 4. Is the Imam al-Haramayn a jurisprudential school whose opinion is to be taken? And did Abu Hanifa err in his opinion permitting ablution before the time for those with excuses, except for Dhuhr? 5. How can apparent (Suri) combining of prayers be a matter of dispute despite the Prophet's (peace and blessings be upon him) hadith to the woman with Istihada (non-menstrual vaginal bleeding): "And if you are able to delay Dhuhr and hasten Asr, then perform Ghusl and combine between the two prayers"? 6. Is the difference in Madhhabs (schools of thought) a mercy? And why is "exiting the disagreement" mentioned in most fatwas? And is it correct to adopt what suits a Muslim from the Madhhabs, or to adopt the more cautious opinion? And is a person considered mistaken or their prayer invalidated if they adopt the Maliki opinion that incontinence does not nullify ablution, out of ease?

2 min readAlso available in العربية

There is no requirement for the second prayer in a "pictorial" (nominal) combination of two prayers to be performed immediately after the first, and performing voluntary (nafl) prayers between them is permissible. The condition of a person suffering from continuous سلس (incontinence) necessitates performing ablution for each prayer after washing and binding the affected area. However, if the impurity ceases for a sufficient period, then purification and prayer should be delayed until that period. Contaminated clothing must be changed unless doing so causes undue hardship.

The imams are in agreement regarding the obligation to follow the Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him. Whoever finds an opinion of an imam that contradicts an authentic hadith has an excuse, such as not believing in the authenticity of the hadith, or not intending to address the issue with that statement, or believing in its abrogation. Following the concessions of the jurisprudential schools of thought without a valid reason is considered فسق (transgression). The hadith "The اختلاف (disagreement/difference) of my Ummah is a mercy" is fabricated, and the hadith "My companions are like stars" is very weak.

The sources of legislation are the Qur'an, the Sunnah, scholarly consensus (Ijma'), and analogical reasoning (Qiyas). Disagreements among scholars are natural and are attributed to differences in understanding the text or its authenticity. It is not permissible to choose opinions based on whims; rather, it should be based on evidence. If a person is unable to do so, they should ask the people of knowledge. Fanaticism weakens the Ummah. Whoever knows an authentic proof for a legal ruling has no excuse for abandoning it. Taking the more cautious approach in legal rulings is commendable. Blameworthy severity (تشدد) is excessive zeal that leads to boredom or exaggeration in supererogatory acts, not taking a concession (رخصة).

Summarized from the full answer at Ftawy · reviewed Sep 2, 2026

Read the full answer on Ftawy