Is the questioner sinful for showing apparent kindness to her mother's relatives, despite her heart disapproving of their actions that violate Islamic law? Is she sinful for maintaining ties with her father without their knowledge? And how can she convince her mother of her position?
"Connecting with your father without the knowledge of your mother and relatives who backbite and spread gossip is not sinful. In fact, connecting with your father is an obligatory act of obedience, and showing kindness to relatives is religiously مطلوب (enjoined), even if they are disobedient. You must gently and wisely forbid them from evil. If you fear harm, there is no sin in refraining from verbal denouncement. Teaching your mother matters of her religion and helping her obey are among the greatest forms of righteousness. You should convince her of the correctness of your stance by explaining the religious ruling and consistently offering advice with courtesy and gentleness, without overburdening her. Supplication is one of the most beneficial means."
Summarized from the full answer at Ftawy · reviewed Sep 2, 2026
Read the full answer on Ftawyhttps://ftawy.com/en/questions/184903