What is the ruling regarding the triple divorce pronounced by the husband in the aforementioned situations?

In the first and second scenarios, the divorce is considered valid and has taken place. A wife's mere refusal to go with her husband or her anger is not considered legitimate duress that prevents the divorce from occurring, unless the anger reaches a state of unconsciousness. As for the third scenario, if the wife threatened to kill herself and carried out the threat if she was not divorced, then the divorce does not occur in this case, because it is considered legitimate duress. We advise the spouses to be keen on understanding each other and not to make divorce a means of solving problems unless its benefit outweighs the harm.