Why do you say that Muhammad is the best of God's creation? The best of God's creation should not have sins, the devil should have no power over him, the devil should not cast verses on his tongue, he should not go against the command of God, magic should not affect him, his parents should not be polytheists, and he should not spread his religion by sword or wealth.

Praise be to Allah.

Firstly: We have read what you have written with your letters, and it is our right upon you to read what we defend with our religion and our Prophet Muhammad, peace and blessings be upon him and upon his brother Jesus, peace be upon him.

Secondly: It is good that the conclusion of your message includes an acknowledgment that Jesus, peace be upon him, is the best of God's creation, and that he is a created being and not divine.

Thirdly: We are not in a position to compare Jesus and Muhammad, peace be upon them, for we are forbidden from preferring one prophet over another.

Fourthly: The discussion of preference between Jesus and Muhammad, peace be upon them, is not intended in religion.

Fifthly: Your statement about our Prophet Muhammad that he is \"a sinner\" is false; we absolve the prophets of sins and wrongdoings.

Sixthly: The story of the cranes is not substantiated by transmission.

Seventhly: The magic that afflicted the Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him, was a disease from diseases.

Eighthly: There is no connection between him being the best of God’s creation and his parents being polytheists.

Ninthly: The spread of Islam was not by the sword but by invitation.

Tenthly: History testifies to the atrocities committed by the Christians in the Crusades and other events.