Is "Al-Mukhtasar fi Tafsir al-Qur'an al-Kareem" sufficient to replace the Tafsir of العلامة السعدي (Allamah Al-Sa'di)?

The book "Al-Mukhtasar fi al-Tafsir" (The Concise Interpretation) is easy to understand, limits itself to interpreting verses without delving into issues of recitations (Qira'at) or jurisprudence (Fiqh), explains unfamiliar vocabulary, follows the methodology of the Salaf in interpretation, and mentions the guidance and benefits of the verses. As for the book "Taysir al-Kareem al-Rahman" (Facilitating the Generous, the Most Merciful) by Al-Sa'di, it is characterized by its easy and clear language, avoidance of verbosity and unnecessary disputes, adherence to the methodology of the Salaf regarding verses of attributes (Sifat), and precise derivation of benefits and rulings. It is considered a book of interpretation and moral education, and the author himself produced a concise version of it. It is recommended to read both books to benefit from the advantages of each. If one cannot read both, Al-Sa'di's interpretation is preferred, along with a book explaining unfamiliar vocabulary. For those who have not read tafsir before, it is recommended to start with "Al-Mukhtasar" and then move on to Al-Sa'di's interpretation.