Is it correct for the imam to be corrected during his prayer when he recites the verse "أم كنتم شهداء إذ حضر يعقوب الموت" (Or were you witnesses when death approached Jacob?) by opening the letter taa' (ت) [i.e., pronouncing "الموتَ" instead of "الموتُ"], especially if the mispronunciation distorts the meaning and constitutes an alteration of Allah's words?
The Imam's advice is an act for which you are rewarded, and correcting a reader's mistake is part of advising for the sake of Allah's Book and for the reader himself. As for the ruling on the prayer of the Imam and the congregant when there is a grammatical error in a verse other than Al-Fatiha, the majority of scholars consider their prayer valid.
A brief overview of the scholars' opinions: - Hanafis: The early scholars invalidated the prayer if the change led to a meaning of disbelief, while later scholars validated it as long as the error was not intentional. - Malikis: The prayer is valid absolutely, unless the error was intentional, in which case it is invalidated. They stipulate four conditions for the validity of the prayer of one who made an unintentional error: inability to learn due to lack of time, absence of a teacher, absence of anyone else to lead the people in prayer, and that the congregant be similar to him or less knowledgeable in recitation. - Shafi'is: The prayer is valid even if the grammatical error changes the meaning, provided that the person is unable to learn or made an error. However, if he is able to learn or intentionally makes the error, his prayer is invalidated. - Hanbalis: The prayer is valid if the Imam made an error. However, if he intentionally made the error, his prayer and the prayer of those who followed him are invalidated.
Summarized from the full answer at Ftawy · reviewed Sep 2, 2026
Read the full answer on Ftawyhttps://ftawy.com/en/questions/36342