Back to search

What is your opinion on Al-Mutanabbi, and is there anything in his poetry that takes him out of the fold of Islam or indicates disbelief?

1 min readAlso available in العربية

Al-Mutanabbi was a famous poet who reached the pinnacle of poetic composition. It was said that he claimed prophethood and was imprisoned for it. His poetry contains doctrinal violations, including:

1. His preference for the sips of his beloved over monotheism, as in his saying: "They sip from my mouth sips... They are sweeter in it than monotheism." 2. His expression of disassociation from Islam if someone like his praised one existed, as in his saying: "If there was or ever will be someone like you... Then I renounce Islam at that time." 3. Exaggeration in praising a created being to the extent of surpassing Jibreel in trustworthiness, as in his saying: "You are so great that even if you were a trust... Jibreel would not be entrusted with it." 4. His use of attributes specific to Allah for the praised one, as in his saying: "O you whom I seek refuge in for what I hope for... And from whom I seek protection from what I fear... People cannot mend a bone that you have broken... Nor can they break a bone that you have mended." 5. Diminishing the status of prophets and miracles, as in his saying: "If your knowledge of God were divided... Among people, God would not have sent a messenger" and "If Dhu al-Qarnayn had used his judgment... When he came to the darknesses, they would have become suns." 6. Excessive arrogance and vanity, as in his saying: "What place shall I ascend... What great one shall I face... And all that God has created, and what He has not created... Is insignificant in my ambition like a hair in my parting."

These examples are considered doctrinal violations attributed to Al-Mutanabbi and have been discussed in specialized studies and research.

Summarized from the full answer at Ftawy · reviewed Sep 2, 2026

Read the full answer on Ftawy