Are the following actions considered polytheism (shirk): 1. A person jokingly says: "A man asked a shaykh, 'Is it permissible to pray without ablution (wudu')?' The shaykh said, 'No.' So the man replied, 'Then what about the one who did it and it worked out for him?'" while not intending to mock prayer or religion? 2. A young man repeatedly utters an obscure word (meaning an insect) instead of the word "Zakat" when reviewing his deeds, without intending to insult Zakat or connect the word to it, but rather it slipped out of him unintentionally before he sought forgiveness?
If a Muslim utters words that suggest the abandonment of an obligation or the commission of a forbidden act, but he does not intend their literal meaning nor to mock the religion, then he neither commits disbelief nor sin. For example, one who prays without ablution intending tayammum, or makes a mistake in the wording of zakat, bears no sin. This is because the Lawgiver has nullified words whose meanings were not intended by the speaker, such as slips of the tongue due to intense joy, anger, or intoxication.
Summarized from the full answer at Ftawy · reviewed Sep 2, 2026
Read the full answer on Ftawyhttps://ftawy.com/en/questions/141122