Back to search

What is the jurisprudential ruling on what the questioner and her female colleagues do by sitting with a male and a female colleague of theirs, which includes seclusion and prolonged conversations between them at work; all this in order to avoid fitna (strife/temptation), suspicions, and gossip among employees? And is this act considered concealing an evil, necessitating punishment? And what is the optimal solution in this situation?

1 min readAlso available in العربية

It is not permissible for a woman to work if it involves private seclusion (khalwa) with non-mahram men or mingling that does not guarantee immunity from temptation. What the girl does by sitting and talking with the young man without necessity is a reprehensible act and contrary to Islamic law. Friendship between a man and a non-mahram woman is wrong. The questioner's participation in sitting with the young man to ward off suspicions is wrong; the correct action is to offer her advice. If she does not respond, then she should abandon and boycott her if she believes that this might bring her back to the right path. Covering up for Muslims is religiously required, but if a person persists in error, the correct action is to inform someone who can change the reprehensible act. What was said about the punishment for concealing an adulterer and adulteress being more severe is incorrect. We advise leaving work where men and women mix. If this is not possible and you are in dire need of work, then it is obligatory to adhere to the limits of Allah and observe the manners of Islamic law. Interaction with non-mahram men should be without khalwa, with adherence to the legal hijab, lowering the gaze, and speaking seriously and modestly, limited to what is necessary. You should associate with righteous women and learn the rulings of Islamic law.

Summarized from the full answer at Ftawy · reviewed Sep 2, 2026

Read the full answer on Ftawy