Back to search

How can one deal with a daughter who is unconcerned by her father's financial hardship and considers her right upon him to be paramount, even if it forces him into debt? Is this behavior considered an act of disobedience to parents?

1 min readAlso available in العربية

The impulsiveness and rebelliousness of girls towards their parents often stem from one of two reasons: a religious/faith-based reason or a psychological/behavioral one.

The Religious/Faith-Based Reason: This relates to a weakness or distortion in the children's perception of the status of parents in Islam and their rights. Islamic texts emphasize filial piety and good companionship, even if the child differs with their parents in religion. They also state that communication with them should be gentle, humble, and in a lowered voice, and that one should not reprimand them or refuse them something they desire. The second problem is the dissatisfaction of some children with what Allah has apportioned for them in worldly fortunes, and their constant gaze at those who are wealthier than them, which drives them to discontent and dissatisfaction. Children should remember that Allah's provision is better and more enduring than the fleeting bloom of worldly life. It must be known that the father is commanded to spend according to his capacity, not according to the children's desires. Therefore, it is not permissible for children to burden him beyond his capability or to make him feel inadequate.

The Psychological/Behavioral Reason: Impulsiveness may be pathological, resulting from an inability to control oneself, and it appears with anxiety and stress disorders, or borderline personality disorder. In this case, if admonition and discipline are ineffective, it is recommended to consult a psychiatrist to assess the condition and consider appropriate pharmaceutical and behavioral treatment.

Summarized from the full answer at Ftawy · reviewed Sep 2, 2026

Read the full answer on Ftawy