Is the story true that Umar said to Abu Hurayrah: "O enemy of Allah and His Messenger, you have stolen Allah's money"?

This narration was reported by Al-Hakim, who authenticated its chain of transmission, and Al-Dhahabi concurred. It revolves around a dialogue between Umar and Abu Hurayrah, where Umar accused Abu Hurayrah of betraying Allah’s money. Abu Hurayrah denied this, explaining that the money was the price of his camels and shares he had accumulated. Umar then fined him twelve thousand. Afterwards, Abu Hurayrah prayed for Umar’s forgiveness. When Umar offered him the position again, Abu Hurayrah refused, justifying his refusal by saying that he feared speaking and issuing fatwas without knowledge, and that his back would be beaten, his honor insulted, and his wealth taken by force.

There is nothing in this narration that should please the people of innovation who disparage the Companions. Umar’s statement, "O enemy of Allah and enemy of Islam," was uttered in a state of anger and was not intended literally. The people of Sunnah do not claim infallibility for the Companions. Had Umar truly considered Abu Hurayrah an enemy of Allah, he would not have desired to appoint him again.

This narration contains indications of the virtues of the two noble Companions: Abu Hurayrah’s piety and asceticism concerning positions, and his good nature and purity of heart shown by his prayer for Umar despite being rebuked and having his wealth taken. It also shows Umar’s diligence in safeguarding public funds, his accountability of governors, and his adherence to truth.