Does Islamic jurisprudence stipulate a minimum of three witnesses for a punishment or any worldly matter?
The issue is permissible only for three types of individuals: a man who undertakes a financial guarantee (hamalah) until he fulfills it and then abstains, a man whose wealth has been swept away by a calamity (jaihah) so that the issue becomes permissible for him until he acquires a subsistence living, and a man afflicted by destitution (faqah) until three people of sound judgment from his community attest to his poverty, whereupon the issue becomes permissible for him until he acquires a subsistence living. Some jurists have used this hadith as evidence for requiring three witnesses to prove the poverty of someone who was once wealthy, while the majority (jumhur) said: the testimony of two just witnesses is acceptable, like in cases other than adultery, and they interpreted the hadith as being recommendatory.
Summarized from the full answer at Ftawy · reviewed Sep 2, 2026
Read the full answer on Ftawyhttps://ftawy.com/en/questions/56964