Is the man mentioned in the hadith obligated to seek forgiveness from the woman he assaulted, and what is your opinion of those who claim that the hadith indicates Islam's leniency regarding harassment?
The story mentioned is established in the Sahih collections, Sunan, and Musnad, and there is nothing in it that explicitly indicates coercion of the woman. The man's statement, "I wrestled with a woman," may simply mean flirting or jesting, as some commentators have suggested, and not necessarily a struggle or coercion. If the woman was compliant, then she brought it upon herself. Assuming coercion, there is no certainty that he did not seek her forgiveness, as seeking forgiveness is part of completing repentance concerning the rights of people.
The claim that Islam condones harassment is incorrect. Islam prohibits heinous acts and provides preventive measures such as forbidding mixing (of genders), seclusion, lowering the gaze, and enjoining women to wear hijab and dress modestly. Those who accuse Islam of this are more deserving of accusation themselves, for in the name of personal freedoms, they unleash women to dress, uncover, and go out without restrictions, which entices and pushes others to exploit them and lead them into immorations. This results in unknown parentage and negative consequences due to the absence of noble values.
Summarized from the full answer at Ftawy · reviewed Sep 2, 2026
Read the full answer on Ftawyhttps://ftawy.com/en/questions/193719